Overwhelmed when it comes to choosing a kitchen countertop? We sympathize. We've been through more than a dozen remodels among us; interested in our findings? Read on.
We have experience with several different kitchen countertop materials, and we all have our favorites; for Francesca and Michelle, it's marble, Sarah and Christine favor stainless steel, Julie likes laboratory countertops, and I'm partial to soapstone. Have experience with any of these materials (or others we've left off the list)? Feel free to weigh in.
MARBLE
Above: Francesca's kitchen prep area features a counter made of statuary marble (it's whiter than Carrara marble and features bold gray veining). It's important to choose slabs carefully and be sure to mark the seam areas, so that the variations match up pleasingly (this often requires several trips to the stone yard). ABC Stone Trading in Brooklyn is an excellent source for marble slab for countertops.
Above: Michelle is in the process of a remodel. "All the stone in the house—countertops, backsplash, thresholds, sills, bathrooms—will be carrara marble for these reasons: the color is neutral, it works equally well on countertops and floors, and buying four slabs of a single type stone seemed the most cost efficient approach," she says.
STAINLESS STEEL
Above: Christine's countertop of choice is stainless steel. "I love the industrial clean feel and the patina it acquires from years of use," she says. Stainless-steel countertops can be found at restaurant suppliers; for an online source that ships, try A-Line Stainless Countertops. Photo via Messana O'Rorke Architects.
Above: The thin flat top stainless kitchen counters in a kitchen by architect Jerome Buttrick have an appealing modern look and offer a cost savings over the traditional practice of wrapping the counter edges.
SOAPSTONE
Above: My kitchen countertops over the years have included granite, stainless, wood, and soapstone (a favorite for its color, feel, heat-resistance, and durability) as pictured in this Maine cottage renovation by architect Sheila Narusawa. It's called soapstone because of the soft feel of the surface, which is due to the presence of talc in the stone. Green Mountain Soapstone has an informative site. Perfectionists take note: Soapstone will show signs of wear and will develop a patina over time. Photo via Justine Hand's Design Skool.
CONCRETE
Above: If I have another kitchen remodel in my future, I think I will look into hard-wearing concrete counters, as used in this kitchen by architect Ken Levenson. Unlike the concrete counters of the late-1980s, which were poured onsite, most concrete counters are precast and come in a huge range of colors and finishes from rough hewn to refined. Levenson used Get Real Surfaces, a source of concrete countertops in New York. Photo courtesy of Levenson McDavid.
Above: Concreteworks in Oakland, California offers a wide range of concrete countertops, including sustainable concrete blends with high recycled content such as fly ash and rice husks. Pictured above is the kitchen at Heath Ceramics in Los Angeles.
Above: An option worthy of serious consideration: the eco-friendly Squak Mountain Stone Composite Countertop. Developed by an entrepreneur as part of her master’s thesis (she was attempting to produce a building material using only locally sourced and recycled materials), the countertop is made from Portland cement, waste fly ash, waste glass dust, mixed waste paper, and pigments. Coated with a food-grade acrylic sealant and buffed to a sheen, the material is stain resistent and warm to the touch. Photo via Sunset. See a slideshow of Earth-Friendly Kitchen Counters at Sunset.
WOOD
Above: Wood countertops, as featured in this Los Angeles kitchen by Aqua Vitae, lack the heat resistance of some of the other options, but offer built-in cutting surface and a soft (break-resistant) texture. John Boos Classic Maple Butcher Block Countertops are 1.5 inches thick and come in a variety of lengths and widths. Boos offers three different types of wood: hard rock maple, red oak, and lyptus, a dark wood similar to cherry. Maintenance includes periodic oiling; nicks and burns can be lightly sanded and the surface reoiled. Photo courtesy of Aqua Vitae.
Above: Ikea offers the affordable oiled-beech Numerar Wood Countertop, which comes in precut lengths. A countertop measuring 49 5/8 by 25 5/8 by 1 1/2 inches is $89.
SOLID SURFACE COMPOSITE
Above: Julie used laboratory countertops in her Mill Valley home. Tacoma, WA-based Richlite makes durable, warm-to-the-touch countertops from resin-impregnated wood pulp from certified forests; go to Richlite for dealer information. Available in a range of colors.
Above: Corian is a solid surface countertop made from a durable nonporous acrylic polymer that comes in over 130 colors. It can also be used for cabinet fronts and sinks.
Above: Used in custom projects by Henrybuilt, one of our favorite kitchen-design outfits, Finnish-made Durat is a polyester-based solid-surface material resistant to wear, humidity, and chemicals. Made of 30 percent recycled post-industrial plastic, Durat is 100 percent recyclable, is available in 70 colors, and can be renewed with a light sanding.
Above: The popular and highly-rated quartz-based CaesarStone countertop is made from ground quartz that is non-porous, scratch resistant, and highly resistant to stains. It doesn't require sealants or waxes. CaesarStone countertops come in a wide range of colors and textures. Go to CaesarStone for dealer information.
Read more: 6 Great Countertops: How to Choose the Best Material - Popular Mechanics
N.B.: This post is an update; the original story ran on June, 5 2009.